Standing Conference on Problems Associated with the Coastline
Mr Lyall Cairns, Eastern Solent Coastal Partnership
Mr Matt Hosey, Poole Borough Council
Mr Neil Watson, Environment Agency
Dr Samantha Cope, Havant Borough Council
Strategies & Plans
The Regional Habitat Compensation Programme (RHCP) is a strategic programme run by the Environment Agency.
The RHCP is the Government’s agreed mechanism for delivering strategic habitat compensation for Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management (FCERM) to ensure compliance with the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 (commonly referred to as the Habitats Regulations). The compensatory requirement passed on to the RHCP from Shoreline Management Plans (SMPs) is the amount of habitat required to address the adverse impacts on European sites from the SMP policies due to coastal squeeze and saline inundation impacts.
In the Solent and South Downs area, the Eastern Solent Coastal Partnership (ESCP) is working with the Environment Agency to deliver the programme. The Solent and South Downs RHCP covers the area from Hurst Spit in the west to Beachy Head in the east and includes the north coast of the Isle of Wight.
The Solent and South Downs area habitat compensation requirements were calculated from predicted habitat losses within each relevant European site, using data from the Solent Dynamic Coast Project (SDCP) (2008) for the North Solent SMP and the Isle of Wight Mitigation Study (2006) for the Isle of Wight SMP. Habitat losses which could not be mitigated through the SMP policies within the European sites were passed onto the RHCP for delivery as compensation. These calculations and the agreed habitat compensation requirements are described in the Appropriate Assessments (AAs) for the North Solent and Isle of Wight SMPs, which were both adopted in 2010. The Secretary of State approved the SMP AAs and the RHCP as the strategic compensation mechanism via a derogation under the Habitats Regulations (often referred to as the IROPI agreement). The IROPI decision confirmations are made available below:
An AA was not undertaken for the Beachy Head to Selsey Bill SMP as this was a pilot SMP2 undertaken before the requirement for Habitats Regulation Assessment was realised. Therefore, there are no habitat requirements currently recorded for the Beachy Head to Selsey Bill SMP but this is recommended to be addressed in future work and may be picked up via the planned SMP refresh.
Solent and South Downs Habitat Compensation Targets
The habitat types that are relevant to the Solent and South Downs RHCP are:
These are the same habitat groups that were used in the SMP Appropriate Assessments to ensure clear and transparent tracking of habitat compensation requirements through consistent calculation of habitat losses and gains.
We have provided a strategic update on the habitat compensation targets for the Solent and South Downs RHCP by reviewing and combining the requirements from the two relevant SMP IROPI agreements: North Solent and Isle of Wight. A summary of the combined habitat balance for the Solent and South Downs area is provided in Table 1.
Regional Habitat Creation Programme
Table 1 indicates that over the 100-year SMP period, the Solent and South Downs RHCP needs to create the following compensation to offset habitat losses that will arise from the SMP policies:
In addition to the SMP habitat compensation requirements, the Environment Agency has also previously committed to creating habitat to address estimated historic losses from coastal squeeze across protected areas. Separate targets (referred to as PSA targets) were established in 2007 for each estuary complex that were considered the minimum needed to begin site recovery. The habitat creation target agreed to address historic losses for the Solent estuary group was 100 ha of intertidal habitat. This figure has been incorporated into the progress review discussed below.
Progress towards meeting Solent and South Downs RHCP targets
Several habitat compensation schemes have already been completed in the Solent and South Downs area. These are described below.
Lymington Water Level Management Plan
Implemented in September 2010, this compensation scheme re-established tidal exchange in the Lymington River through the introduction of self-regulating tide gates at the Bridge Road crossing. The reedbed increased upstream and laterally as willow scrub died back and woodland retreated 5-20 metres inland. The reedbed cover increased from 40% in 2009 to 90% in 2014. Rank fen vegetation and nettles died off as a result of saline inundation. Invasive non-native species present in 2009 were largely removed from the reedbed by 2014. Overall, this compensation scheme created 21 hectares of tidal reedbeds upstream of the bridge.
Medmerry Managed Realignment Scheme
Completed in 2013, this compensation scheme created 183 hectares of new intertidal habitat comprising of 158 hectares of saltmarsh and 25 hectares of mudflat. It is the largest open coast managed realignment scheme in Europe. In addition to the intertidal habitats, there are also reedbeds and freshwater ponds and ditches that provide habitat for water voles and aquatic invertebrates. The site is managed as a nature reserve by the RSPB and has already seen increasing populations of breeding and wintering wildfowl and wading birds - a highlight was a pair of black-winged stilts successfully breeding in 2014.
Photo: courtesy of the Environment Agency
Manor House Farm
This site in the lower Test Valley was identified as a potential area to create floodplain grazing marsh and other wetland habitats and the Environment Agency purchased the site in 2018. It is predicted to create 69 hectares of freshwater marsh. With sea level rise and increasing tidal influence, this will eventually become coastal grazing marsh together with an additional 16 hectares of freshwater habitats (such as ponds, reedbeds and wet woodland). The creation of these habitats will reduce the RHCP target for coastal grazing marsh habitat from 76 hectares to 7 hectares and there will be a net gain of 12 hectares of freshwater habitats.
Photo: courtesy of the Environment Agency
Live Habitat Balance Sheet for the Solent and South Downs RHCP
The creation of compensatory habitats at Lymington, Medmerry and Manor House Farm has resulted in the updated habitat balances for the Solent and South Downs RHCP shown in Table 2 below. In summary, all the historic (pre-SMP) habitat requirements have been met and the RHCP targets for Epoch 1 have nearly been met, with a remaining 20 ha of saltmarsh compensation outstanding.
Future Habitat Compensation Opportunities
As discussed above, there is still an urgent need for habitat compensation to meet the remaining RHCP targets. Following the implementation of the completed schemes described above, the remaining habitat compensation targets for the Solent and South Downs area are shown in Table 3.
* The saltmarsh compensation requirement in Epoch 3 has increased by 4 ha from the 163 ha stated in the baseline requirements to 167 ha due to habitat creation at Lymington being used to offset historic losses and therefore no longer being available to count as mitigation for the SMP policies as was previously included in the North Solent SMP AA.
The Solent and South Downs RHCP is currently focused on creating saltmarsh habitat as there is an urgent need to create an additional 20 ha of this habitat type in the current epoch and saltmarsh is predicted to have the greatest area of loss over the next 100 years. Saltmarsh provides important feeding grounds for birds, nursery areas for small fish and habitat for rare invertebrate species.
The RHCP has identified potential sites in the Solent and South Downs area for saltmarsh habitat creation opportunities. These sites have been prioritised based on how likely it is that they could be implemented as there are many barriers to managed realignment, such as the physical characteristics of the site, landowner concerns, opposition from communities, presence of infrastructure and/or utilities and the potential loss of important landward freshwater habitats and bird roosting and feeding sites. The Environment Agency and the ESCP are working to progress the best sites for habitat creation.
Meeting the habitat creation targets in the Solent and South Downs RHCP is a legal requirement and is essential to ensuring that FCERM schemes can continue to be delivered for communities in our area.
The full Solent and South Downs RHCP Strategic Update report is available below:
For more information on the Solent and South Downs RHCP please use the following contacts:
Annual Review Report 2017 (pdf, 3Mb)